jester1534 wrote:monsterpile wrote:Camden0916 wrote:bleedspeed177 wrote:White Sox get Keuchel at 3 years, $55.5 million
Yep, that's gross. That's a bad deal in my estimation.
What's a few extra million though right?!?! Lol Bumgarner taking less clearly makes this deal look really bad. I don't think I see it as a value deal overall. Just to compare tho Gibson got 3-30 and while Keuchel isn't the guy he once was I think it's fair to say he has a better track record and worth more than Gibson especially depending on the rest of your roster (infield defense). I'm blanking on what they have for starters outside of Giolito. I'm perfectly fine on them passing on that deal for Dallas K.
Honestly Monster theres a case where Gibson outpiched Kuechel last year based on advance metrics. Kuechel has 4.76 FIP and Gibson had 4.3 FIP
Yeah that's fair. It's also worth remembering Keuchel came in and pitched without the typical spring training etc. Pitching is a pretty inexact science and that's why team pay and fans clamor for the guys that if they are healthy you know they are gonna be pretty good.