FNG wrote: ↑Sat Aug 01, 2026 4:14 pm
AussieWolf3 wrote: ↑Sat Aug 01, 2026 3:34 pm
What is the argument for Lyles at 4 and Jaden at 3 besides simply googling their ht/wt measurements?
I'll get in front of the obvious point which is that Jaden staring at SF is the status quo, so why disrupt that? To which the obvious reply is that the status quo was already disturbed when they swapped Randle and Naz for LaMelo and Green, so that point loses weight right off the bat.
I find it very hard to believe that Lyles will be a more positive contributor than Jaden as a 4. However, what's nice about a player like Lyles and perhaps a roster with a less set in stone pecking order is that you can up Lyles minutes in certain matchups and slide Jaden over to the 3.
Fair question, especially since we don't know what Lyles has left in the tank after a year away from the NBA. But assuming he is capable of handling a starting role (and he may not be) here's the argument. You mentioned the first point...it would be nice to have someone who has both the length and bulk to defend PFs. More importantly, having someone who is big enough to defend 4's allows Finchy to use Jaden in the role he prefers him in...guarding the opponent's most potent wing. Finally, Ayo has been mentioned as a possible 5th starter at SF if Jaden has to play the 4...there are several on this board that think Ayo's best role is as a high-scoring 6th man.
Again, were relying on Google measurements.
I've literally watched Jaden defend 4s, and I have presume you have too. He handles himself fine against most, a lot of which he's actually taller and longer than. As far as weight, Google Jaden and Kawhi... People trying to sell that Jaden is only 2 inches taller and 40 pounds lighter..... Ok
Here's what I see. Jaden has gotten worse year over year as a perimeter defender. Kid has one all defensive team to his name and we act like he elite here. He hasn't been, empirically, even if the data set (media awards) is flawed.
Obviously watching Jaden looking like the stuff of Jamaal Murray's nightmares this PS was inspired, but that isn't what you're getting all season. Jaden also has a burgeoning offensive game that is much harder to tap into if he continues to commit this much energy to the POA.
You know what Jaden has gotten really good at? Backside rim protection. He's as good as it gets at filling in behind Rudy when he has to play up on the PnR, in a way that completely alters the defense and how we all would plead for Julius to do. Jaden is also a dog, so are we really gonna at like he won't dig in down low and fight for boards?
Having someone like Jaden who had the length and yes, I believe the size, to man the pf position who can also switch onto guards is a powerful weapon and it's gotten completely ignored in this conversation where everyone has basically memeified Jaden's defense. Apparently the NBA is filled with Charles Barkleys this year with elite post up games. "Behemoths" has been thrown around a lot, such a the indomitable P.J. Washington who is all of *lowers eyeglasses* 6 ft 6 and 220 lbs...... A real monster.
Lyles who clearly has more bulk to him, more than most PFs tbh, will be a useful tool against bigger matchups and honestly I'm pretty excited about the idea that you can sub him in and slide Jaden up to the 3.
Now the big question: who plays SF if Jaden plays PF? Well this is kind of become a non issue to me despite the overall consensus that has grown which is that Jaden is still gonna have to defend the perimeter even if he is nominally a big. An assertion that I find perplexing given the abundance of wing defenders: Ayo, Clark, Green, Ant, TJ and eventually Dante. Are any of them besides Clark as good as Jaden? Probably not, but the combination and versatility of a Jaden plus whoever emerges as the best defenders from this group will certainly be better than Jaden and Julius, cause Julius is a horrible horrible defender (did we all forget that?).
Obviously there was a loss of size with Naz and Ju going out and I would have loved to have someone like Jonathon Issac as a tool, but imo the versatility has improved, by a lot, imo