longstrangetrip wrote:
I like Thorpe too, Jerry, and am not opposed to drafting Hield at 5 (although not my first choice), but I do have issues with some of Thorpe's assertions. I don't want to gin up the age discrimination discussion again, but Thorpe's comment that Hield would be #1 if he were a freshman this year is flawed logic. Hield as a freshman averaged only 8 PPG and only 24% on threes, not good enough to be the #1 pick in the draft. Thorpe means to say "If Hield put up in his freshman year the same stats he put up his senior year, he would be #1". I don't disagree, but it's an absurd concept. Hield's actual stats as a freshman is the only valid comparison we have to the other freshmen in this year's draft.
I also take issue with his assertion that Hield has been a very good long-distance shooter for the past three years. While he had a stellar senior year shooting 3's at 46%, his junior year 3-point 36% rate is only average. I'm always skeptical of college players who make a big leap ahead in shooting percentage their final year in college, because I often find it's not sustainable in the pros. Many of us (including me) fell for the Victor Oladipo hype when he dramatically improved his 3-point shooting his junior year to 44%, but in his first three years in the NBA he has proven to be what we should have known he was by his early college years...a below average 3-point shooter.
And I find the Steph Curry comparison flawed also. Curry shot over 41% on threes for his entire 3-year college career, and actually had his highest percentages his first two years.
I think Hield will likely be a pretty good NBA player, but I didn't find Thorpe's article about him to be his best work.
One counter example about guy whom shot three pointers well only in his senior season (41.8%) but has been even more successful in NBA is Danny Green. Of course he struggled in beginning to even get any minutes in NBA but even then he shot really well three pointers in D-league. Weirdest thing is that he shot terribly treys when he played one season in Europe. Even with shorter line he wasn't able to hit 30% of his 3-pointers but after joining Spurs, he had four consecutive seasons with better than 40% 3P%.
Wesley Matthews is maybe another valid example. He had good 3P% as freshman but since he hit just 14 three pointers, good 3P% was mainly just good luck. He struggled to hit 30% of his three pointers in next two seasons and finally asa senior he his 36.8% with pretty nice volume (42/114). He has beenmuch more successful in NBA from the very beginning.