Q12543 wrote:The problem Lip is that Wiggins' length doesn't really translate into results on the defensive side of the ball. We've talked ad nauseam about his mediocre rebounding and lack of blocks/deflections/steals. He gets man handled by bigger wings. After three seasons in the league, he has put on minimal weight, so I'm skeptical that he's suddenly going to pack on another 15 lbs. of muscle.
That being said, I do think he can still play SF to finish games, where teams tend to downsize significantly anyway. It's the start of halves where I'd prefer to have a bigger, stronger lineup and a big wing defender next to him that can take some of the defensive and rebounding pressure off of Wiggins. Then may be he'll have the legs and energy to perform better in crunch time.
I don't think size is Wiggins problem on the defensive end. Watching him live in close to 120 home games the past three years, I see his defensive failings primarily as a function of his inconsistent motor and his learning curve understanding how to defend. I've seen him get out-quicked more than I've seen him overpowered. He and KAT have both been way too matador-like on defense. Wiggins is listed at 6'8, 199. Compare that to some SFs on playoff teams around the League - many of them regarded as excellent defenders:
Bazemore - 6'5, 201
DeMarre Carroll - 6'8, 212
Otto Porter - 6'8, 198
Kelly Oubre - 6'7, 205
Iggy - 6'6, 215
Ariza - 6'8, 215
James Ennis - 6'7, 210
Jonathon Simmons.- 6'6, 195
McDermott - 6'8, 219
Andre Roberson - 6'7, 210
Yes, there are much beefier SFs like Leonard. But the ones I listed are all good players, many of them good defenders and none have the hops or overall athleticism of Andrew Wiggins. Compared to these guys it's obvious that Wiggins isn't some pewee who is too small physically to defend at the SF position. On the offensive end, Wiggins doesn't have the ball-handling skills of a top NBA SG. Some of it comes down to matchups. But overall, I see Wiggins as more of a SF than SG and his size is in line with a number of currently successful NBA SFs.
That said, it doesn't look like we're going to ever get much rebounding out of Wiggins. So I do see merit to pairing him with another (probably bigger) wing who rebounds. On the other hand, we absolutely have to have a top 3-point shooter on the floor with Wiggins to spread the floor and provide for more efficient scoring. If not, we won't have any good 3-point shooters on the floor in our starting lineup and that's totally unacceptable in today's NBA. Moreover, we were actually a pretty good rebounding team last season with KAT, Gorgui and Ricky among the better rebounders at their respective positions.