TheFuture wrote:There are a lot of bigs I'd trade harden for. I see him like melo. Puts up big numbers but won't lead to championships. Plus, his defense is the most embarrassing thing I've ever seen.
So ibaka, Millsap, cousins, vucevic, Aldridge, griffin, favors, love, bosh, Drummond, Monroe, gasol, horford, Noah are all bugs I'd trade him for.
This is flat out one of the most absurd comments I have ever seen. The first MASSIVE mistake you made is to reference a championship as a point of differentiation. Do you even realize how many championships those guys have? You listed 14 players, and 1 has a championship (Bosh).
Let's see, the Rockets are 14-6 without Dwight Howard this season. This is virtually 100% contributed with what Harden brings to these games. Just look at his game stats....he is a machine. He is flat out the most dynamic SG, if not the most dynamic guard in the entire NBA. The difference between Melo and Harden is fairly large, and it is driven by Harden's ability to get to the FT line at will and the fact that he is an elite 3 point shooter. Both are terrible defenders. That being said, no one wins a championship by themselves, so it is also absurd to state that this guy, or that guy can't win. Put the right GROUP of guys together, and these guys both could play key parts to a championship.
And it is just funny that you reference defense as a key "detractor" for Harden, when some of your bigs are equally bad (i.e Cousins, Vucevic, Love, Griffin). Not a great arguement with this list overall.